Finny x Reader: Cutie

"Everyone, there will be a new servant here in the Phantomhive mansion. I want everyone to treat her well. She'll be working with Finny. She has a liking towards flowers," Sebastian announced to the chef, gardener and maid. They all look very happy that someone else is joining them.

"She? So it's a girl! Yay! I won't be the only woman here. I wonder what she will look like... I'm very happy, yes I am!" Mey-Rin said, clapping her hands together.

"I bet she will be a beauty! I can show her how to cook like I can!" Bardroy said, holding up his blowtorch.

Finny was the only one that stayed quiet, thinking of the many ways on what she'll look like. He was hoping that she would be very pretty. But he didn't really know how to interact with females, as Mey-Rin was one of the few female friends he had.

After a few moments of waiting, they hear a knock on the door.

"Ah, that must be the new girl," Sebastian said, moving towards the door in his usual speed. Finny, Mey-Rin and Bardroy stood in a line, waiting to get a glimpse on the new gardener.

In came a girl with (h/l), (h/c) hair and (e/c) eyes. She looked very cute, in Finny's perspective.

"Welcome, _________," Ciel said, coming down the stairs. "I'm sure, you'll be happy working here,"

"Yes, sir. I'm honoured in working here in the Phantomhive mansion," you said, bowing slightly.

"Call me Ciel. Don't call me 'sir' since it makes me sound old," Ciel said. "Finny, go show her around," he waved his hand, dismissing them.

Finny walked timidly towards you as he blushed slightly. You laugh a bit, thinking on how cute he is.

"You're Finny, right? You're so cute," you say bluntly. This made Finny go even redder.

"Yeah. Well, time to start your tour!" Finny said, taking your hand and he starts to show you the entire mansion and garden. You already knew this was the start to a beautiful friendship.

~Timeskip~

It now has been a month since you had worked with all the other servants of the Phantomhive mansion and you have loved working with them each and every single day. You were currently talking a walk around the beautiful garden. Finny sure did a wonderful job on tending everything by himself. You were sure that one day that yyou would be as good as him, no matter how clumsy he was. Despite his clumsiness, his strength definitely made up for it.

Suddenly, you were stopped when you heard a small cough behind you. You turned around and you saw Finny with a bouquet of beautiful purple and white flowers.

"U-um... this is f-for you, Miss _________," Finny stuttered cutely. You gave him a huge smile and took the bouquet.

"They are beautiful, Finny. And please, don't call me 'miss'. I told you many times that I don't like to be called that. Just call me _________," you said.

"O-okay... _________," Finny said, saying your name by itself for the first time since you have started working here.

"You're such a cutie, you know that right?" you said, poking his cheek softly. He blushed slightly and didn't respond. You two chatted for a while before you said that you had to go put the bouquet in a vase so the don't wilt.

When you turned around, you went straight to your room since there was a spare vase. Next to your bed, there was a full length mirror and you saw that your face was bright red. And that your heart was pounding in your chest.

"Huh... how weird," you said to yourself. But then you just shrugged it off.

~Timeskip~


It's been a year since you had worked in the Phantomhive mansion an you had to say that you had taken a huge liking towards Finny. You thought his smile, eyes, looks, personality and strength was cute. You couldn't help but fall in love with him.

Right now, you were tending the flowers near the gates and you were spying on Finny who was clipping the trees in shape. You sigh, knowing that he would never return his feelings. When he turned to look at you, you quickly look away, blushing ever so slightly.

~Finny's POV~

How can I confess to her? She probably doesn't even like me! But she has called me cute many times... but she definitely meant it in a mutual friendship way... right? Plus, she never looks at me with a second glance whenever I look at her... Maybe I'm too weird to her. Maybe my strength is too abnormal... Or what if my smile creeps her out? This is horrible!

~Normal POV~

You noticed that Finny was a stressed out over something so you thought you might ask him what is wrong. You stood up and walked towards him.

"U-um... Finny? Are you okay? You seem a bit stressed," you said. Funny didn't notice you were there and he fell off his ladder, landing with a soft thud. But when he fell, he accidentally use his strength to hit a huge tree branch which came tumbling towards you.

"Ah! I'm sorry!" You said, not noticing the branch falling on too if you. Before you knew it, everything went black.

~Timeskip~

When you came to, you were in your bedroom and it was dark outside already. You tried to get up but your head hurts. You then heard a soft snoring which caught your attention. You looked up and noticed that Finny was asleep on your lap. He must have carried you to your bedroom.

'What a cutie...' you thought, running your fingers through his soft hair. "Finny... Wake up," you whispered, shaking his shoulders slightly. He stirred a bit then his eyes widened.

"_________? You're awake! I'm so glad you are okay! I'm so sorry about my strength!" Finny cried, tears forming in his eyes. You shook your head and smiled.

"It's fine. And don't worry about your strength. I love it," you said. Finny gave you a huge smile.

"Really?" He asked hopefully. You nodded.

"Yeah... And I also really like you..." You said, whispering the last part.

"Wh-what was that?" Finny asked.

"I... I like you..." You said a bit louder. But Finny looked really confused.

"What?" He asked again. You swore he was going deaf.

"I said I really love you!" You said, almost shouting.

"Don't shout! It doesn't fit you. I heard you the first time," Finny said, with a small smile. You pouted. What a little troublemaker. "And also... I really like you too,"

And with that, the two of you shared a sweet kiss